Glucosamine derived from shrimp shells and glucosamine derived from a fungus have exactly the same chemical formula. On your label, however, they say very different things: the first obliges you to declare an allergen, the second can go into a vegan formula. For chondroitin, the gap is even wider, since it can come from cattle, pigs, chicken, shark or a fermentation tank.
Yes, you can formulate with shellfish-free glucosamine and chondroitin. Glucosamine exists in a fungal version, derived from Aspergillus niger, recognized in Europe as equivalent to crustacean glucosamine for food supplements. Chondroitin exists in bovine, porcine, poultry and fish versions, but also in a version obtained by fermentation followed by sulfation, authorized as a novel food. The source you choose determines the allergens you must declare, your positioning and the list of documents to require from your supplier.
What these actives are worth clinically, we covered in our comparison of joint supplement ingredients. Here, we talk about origin, labeling and traceability.
Where does glucosamine come from, with or without shellfish?
Historically, glucosamine is obtained by hydrolysis of the chitin contained in crustacean shells. This is the implicit reference in the regulation: in the Union list of novel foods, the entries for glucosamine refer, for their conditions of use, to "the normal food use of glucosamine from crustaceans".
The most established alternative is fungal. It comes from the acid hydrolysis of Aspergillus niger biomass, a co-product of the fermentation used to produce citric acid. A first version was deemed substantially equivalent to crustacean glucosamine in the United Kingdom in 2004, for use in food supplements. The Food Safety Authority of Ireland issued opinions of the same type in 2008, then again a few years later for another manufacturer, with a labeling condition: stating the non-crustacean origin and the source fungus (FSAI, substantial equivalence opinion).
Consulted on a use in everyday foods, EFSA deemed a glucosamine from Aspergillus niger safe for adults at 750 mg per day, while noting that the absence of protein in a purified ingredient does not entirely rule out allergenic potential (EFSA, 2009).
Crustacean-derived glucosamine: do you have to declare the allergen?
Yes. Annex II of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 lists in point 2 "crustaceans and products thereof", with no exception whatsoever. Fish, soybeans, milk and cereals containing gluten benefit from targeted exceptions, such as fully refined soybean oil; crustaceans, none. A glucosamine obtained from shells remains a product derived from crustaceans, whatever its degree of purification.
In practice, the allergen must be emphasized through the typeset in the list of ingredients (Article 21). Our position is simple: if your specification says "shellfish-free", do not settle for a marketing statement. Require documentary proof of the fungal origin: a specification that names the source strain, the regulatory status of the exact ingredient you are buying, and the allergen statement from the production site, including cross-contamination.
Bovine, porcine, poultry, fish or fermentation: which origin for chondroitin?
Commercial chondroitin production relies mainly on animal tissues, bovine, porcine and avian, and on marine sources including shark and other fish (Saha et al., 2024). These origins do not yield quite the same molecule: its structure varies with species and tissue, blends of sources are possible, and extraction can modify it further. Hence a genuine traceability issue, which validated analytical methods (electrophoresis, enzymatic HPLC, size-exclusion chromatography) can address (Volpi, 2019).
Each origin has implications for your range:
- Bovine: no regulated allergen to declare. Your buyers will ask for the origin of the animals and the associated health guarantees.
- Porcine: no allergen either, but it closes the door on halal or kosher ranges.
- Poultry: compatible with a pork-free, fish-free and shellfish-free formula. It remains of animal origin, so it is incompatible with a vegetarian claim.
- Shark or other fish: fish allergen to declare. The Annex II exceptions for fish only cover certain gelatins and isinglass.
- Fermentation and sulfation: a chondroitin produced by a non-genetically modified strain of Escherichia coli, then chemically sulfated, is included in the Union list of novel foods. Conditions: food supplements for adults, excluding pregnant and breastfeeding women, 1,200 mg per day maximum, with a mandatory statement specifying that it is obtained by microbial fermentation and sulfation (Implementing Regulation (EU) 2017/2470).
A plant-based route is also emerging: a chondroitin extracted from the fungus Tremella fuciformis was the subject in 2025 of a consultation on its status, published by the European Commission, which concludes that it is a novel food. It will therefore need to be authorized before it can be marketed in Europe.
The source table, at a glance
| Source | Allergen to declare (Annex II) | Possible positioning | Watch point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crustacean glucosamine | Crustaceans | No vegetarian claim | Emphasis in the list of ingredients |
| Fungal glucosamine (Aspergillus niger) | None | Shellfish-free, vegan | Regulatory status of the exact ingredient, statement of origin |
| Bovine chondroitin | None | Fish-free, shellfish-free | Origin of the animals, health guarantees |
| Porcine chondroitin | None | Fish-free, shellfish-free | Excluded from halal and kosher ranges |
| Poultry chondroitin | None | Fish-free, pork-free | Animal origin |
| Shark or fish chondroitin | Fish | Shellfish-free | Species to document |
| Fermentation chondroitin | None | Vegan | Adults, 1,200 mg per day maximum, mandatory statement |
| Eggshell membrane (including Reggenerate®, native eggshell membrane) | Egg | Ovo-vegetarian, fish-free, shellfish-free, pork-free | Glucosamine and chondroitin present at low levels |
Does eggshell membrane really contain glucosamine and chondroitin?
Yes, and it is documented. A component-by-component analysis of the glycosaminoglycans in the hen's egg showed that chondroitin sulfates and hyaluronic acid are abundant in the membrane (Liu et al., 2014). For a partially hydrolyzed eggshell membrane, its manufacturer published contents of up to 1% glucosamine, 2% chondroitin sulfate, 2% hyaluronic acid and 25% type I collagen, on a dry weight basis (Ruff et al., 2009). These figures concern a membrane other than Reggenerate®, and contents vary with the raw material and the process.
Let's be honest about what that represents. At these maximum contents, a daily dose of 300 mg of membrane provides at most 3 mg of glucosamine and 6 mg of chondroitin. The GAIT trial tested 1,500 mg of glucosamine and 1,200 mg of chondroitin per day (Clegg et al., 2006). Eggshell membrane therefore does not replace the studied doses of isolated glucosamine or chondroitin. That is not what its trials measure anyway: they test the whole matrix, where collagen, elastin, hyaluronic acid and glycosaminoglycans come together, and a 2024 meta-analysis synthesized seven randomized placebo-controlled trials (García-Muñoz et al., 2024).
For the same reason, we advise our clients against presenting the membrane as a "source of glucosamine" on pack. The contents do not justify it, and the wording looks like a nutrition claim that the Annex to Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006 does not provide for these substances. Have this point validated by your regulatory team.
Which combination for which positioning?
Once the sources are known, the combinations take shape quickly:
- Vegan formula: fungal glucosamine and fermentation chondroitin. Eggshell membrane is excluded, since it comes from egg.
- Ovo-vegetarian formula, fish-free and shellfish-free: the same two actives, to which an eggshell membrane can be added to bring collagen, elastin and hyaluronic acid in a single ingredient. Only one allergen to declare, egg.
- Fish-free but non-vegetarian formula: bovine or poultry chondroitin, with fungal glucosamine if you also want to rule out crustaceans.
- Low-dose formula, single capsule or gummy: eggshell membrane alone, without trying to display glucosamine or chondroitin at doses a small format cannot hold.
In all cases, the origin changes nothing about the message allowed on the label. In 2009, EFSA issued an unfavorable opinion on glucosamine, alone or combined with chondroitin, and the maintenance of joints (EFSA, 2009). Brands rely on nutrients with an authorized claim, such as vitamin C (normal collagen formation for the normal function of cartilage) or manganese (normal formation of connective tissue). Check the exact wording in the EU Register of health claims.
Our approach at Circul'Egg
At Circul'Egg, we chose to keep the membrane in its native, non-hydrolyzed form, separated from the shell by a 100% mechanical, solvent-free process. The matrix thus retains the actives it naturally contains: type I, V and X collagen, elastin, hyaluronic acid, glucosamine and chondroitin. We recommend it at 300 mg per day, a dose that fits in a capsule, a tablet, a gummy, a powder or a bar.
Reggenerate®, native eggshell membrane, is developed by Circul'Egg, a company based in Janzé, Brittany, from upcycled eggshells, with ISO and HACCP certifications. Our eggshell membrane guide for formulators details its composition, and our ready-to-market range lets you start from a formula that is already built.
Frequently asked questions
Is fungal glucosamine identical to crustacean glucosamine?
The molecule is the same. The substantial equivalence opinions issued in the United Kingdom and then in Ireland concluded that its composition, nutritional value and use are equivalent to those of crustacean glucosamine in food supplements. The difference lies in the origin, and therefore in allergen labeling and positioning.
Does shark chondroitin have to be declared as fish?
Yes. The exceptions provided for fish only cover certain gelatins and isinglass. A chondroitin extracted from shark cartilage or from another fish falls under the fish allergen.
Can eggshell membrane replace glucosamine in a formula?
Not at an equivalent dose: 300 mg of membrane provides a few milligrams of glucosamine, far from the 1,500 mg studied. Eggshell membrane is an ingredient in its own right, studied as a matrix, and the two approaches can coexist in the same formula.
How do you verify the origin of a chondroitin?
Ask for a specification that names the species and the tissue, and a certificate of analysis that specifies the method used. Electrophoresis or size-exclusion chromatography can characterize the chondroitin and confirm its origin.