Reggenerate logo
EGGSPERTISE

Native vs Hydrolyzed Eggshell Membrane: What Really Changes

08 Nov 2026 • 7 min read

By Chloé Vernet, Sales & Marketing Manager at Circul'Egg

On a technical data sheet, “eggshell membrane” can refer to two ingredients that do not behave the same way at all. Pour them into a glass of water: one does not dissolve, the other does. That difference comes from the process, and it decides almost everything else: the format, the way you present the ingredient, the studies you will be able to cite.

A native eggshell membrane is separated from the shell and milled into a powder without its proteins being cut: it keeps its fibrous structure and remains insoluble. A hydrolyzed membrane is broken down into peptides by enzymatic or chemical means to become water-soluble. Both forms have been tested in randomized placebo-controlled trials, at similar doses (300 to 500 mg per day). The choice between native and hydrolyzed eggshell membrane therefore comes down mainly to your format: drinks on one side, capsules, tablets or gummies on the other.

Why raw eggshell membrane does not dissolve

The shell membrane is a tight network of protein fibers. A recent review describes it as a highly insoluble structure, stabilized by numerous desmosine and isodesmosine cross-links and disulfide bonds. More than 500 proteins have been identified in it, including collagens, glycoproteins and lysozyme, alongside carbohydrates such as hyaluronic acid (Kulshreshtha et al., 2022).

To give an order of magnitude, the membrane used in a Spanish trial contained more than 90% protein, including less than 13% fibrous type I, V and X collagens and at most 4 to 5% elastin, as well as chondroitin sulfate, glucosamine and hyaluronic acid, each below 2% (Cánovas et al., 2022). These figures apply to that product, but they clearly show that this is a matrix, not an isolated molecule.

These cross-links give the membrane its strength and make it insoluble. The same review sees them as the main technical obstacle to its use: hydrolysis was developed to remove that barrier.

How is hydrolyzed eggshell membrane obtained?

There is not one hydrolysis but several, by fermentation, enzymatic or chemical means (Ruff et al., 2015). Three families dominate the literature.

  • Enzymatic hydrolysis, often assisted by a reducing agent that breaks the disulfide bonds. One study combined sodium sulfite and an alkaline protease (Zhao et al., 2019). Another used a keratinase with sodium sulfite: the hydrolysate contained type X collagen peptides of 963 to 2,259 Da and 6.4% glycosaminoglycans (Lien et al., 2022).
  • Alkaline hydrolysis. After micro-milling, hydrolysis with potassium hydroxide (KOH) solubilized around 50% of the membrane's proteins and peptides (Younes et al., 2026).
  • Thermal or acid hydrolysis. Subcritical water, between 180 and 210 °C, yielded a hydrolysate containing proteins, peptides, hyaluronic acid and chondroitin sulfate (Cai et al., 2025).

What to keep in mind for a specification: hydrolysis does not strip the membrane of its glycosaminoglycans, but it turns its fibrous proteins into peptides of varying sizes. The final profile depends on the enzyme, the reagent, the temperature and the duration. Two hydrolyzed membranes can therefore differ from each other as much as they differ from a native membrane.

What does it change in your formula?

In practical terms, solubility is the hydrolysate's main strength. It opens up drinks, shots and dilutable stick packs, formats in which an insoluble powder will not dissolve. For a clear drink, the soluble form is the obvious choice.

Conversely, in a capsule, a tablet, a gummy or a bar, solubility brings little: the ingredient is swallowed or chewed, not dissolved. That is where native membrane finds its place, with a process that is simple to explain.

That leaves the question of digestion. In rats, the digestibility of native membrane protein was measured at 87.0%, versus 94.8% for a hydrolysate, but net protein utilization was identical (84.7% and 84.6%) (Matsuoka et al., 2019). These are animal data, and we have not found a comparable study in humans.

What do the clinical trials say about each form?

Native or minimally processed membranes

  • Membrane described as natural by the authors, 500 mg per day, 67 patients with knee osteoarthritis, 8 weeks: pain and stiffness significantly reduced versus placebo at 10, 30 and 60 days, with no significant difference in function or in the overall WOMAC score (Ruff et al., 2009).
  • Same type of membrane, 500 mg per day, 60 healthy postmenopausal women, 2 weeks of exercise: 17.2% reduction in CTX-II, a marker of cartilage degradation, versus placebo at one week (Ruff et al., 2018).
  • Minimally processed membrane, 300 mg per day, 150 participants, 12 weeks: primary endpoint (numeric pain rating scale) not different from placebo, but KOOS “pain” and “activities of daily living” scores improved from the first week (Kiers and Bult, 2020).

Hydrolyzed membranes

  • Water-soluble hydrolysate, 450 mg per day, 88 adults with knee osteoarthritis, 12 weeks: gains in walking and stiffness in normalized analysis, with no significant difference in raw analysis (Hewlings et al., 2019).
  • Hydrolyzed membrane, 450 mg per day, 88 middle-aged adults, 12 weeks: improvement in the appearance of crow's feet at 4 weeks and of skin tone at 8 weeks, significant effects reported on hair thickness, breakage and growth, no improvement observed on nails (Kalman and Hewlings, 2020).

Other work does not settle the question of form. The trial by Cánovas et al. compared 300 and 500 mg in 80 patients over 8 weeks and observed a dose-dependent response, with only the high dose clearly standing out from placebo on pain. The 2024 meta-analysis, which pools seven randomized trials, concludes that the total WOMAC score improves, without setting native against hydrolyzed in its abstract (García-Muñoz et al., 2024).

Let's be honest: we have found no published trial that directly compares a native membrane and a hydrolyzed membrane within the same study. Each form has its own trials, conducted on specific products, and claiming that one “works better” would go beyond the data.

Native vs hydrolyzed eggshell membrane: the comparison

CriterionNative eggshell membrane (including Reggenerate®)Hydrolyzed eggshell membrane
ProcessSeparation from the shell, then milling into powder, without cutting the proteinsEnzymatic, alkaline, acid or thermal hydrolysis, often with a reducing agent
StructureOriginal fibrous matrix preservedProteins fragmented into peptides, profile varies with the process
CompositionCollagens, elastin, glycosaminoglycans, hyaluronic acid within their matrixPeptides and glycosaminoglycans partly preserved, depending on the process
Water solubilityInsolubleSoluble, fully or partly
Preferred formatsCapsules, tablets, gummies, powders, barsDrinks, shots, dilutable stick packs, capsules
Doses studied300 to 500 mg per day450 mg per day
Examples of published trialsRuff 2009 and 2018, Kiers and Bult 2020 (membranes other than Reggenerate®)Hewlings 2019, Kalman and Hewlings 2020

Why Circul'Egg chose native

At Circul'Egg, we chose to keep the membrane as it is. Reggenerate®, native eggshell membrane, non-hydrolyzed, is obtained through a 100% mechanical, solvent-free process, from upcycled eggshells. No enzyme and no chemical reagent in the process: the matrix stays whole, with its naturally present actives, type I, V and X collagen, elastin, hyaluronic acid, glucosamine and chondroitin.

This choice matches the formats the ingredient was designed for. We recommend 300 mg per day, a dose that fits in a capsule and also works in a tablet, gummy, powder or bar. It is the dose used in the Kiers and Bult trial on a minimally processed membrane. One important clarification: that trial, like all those cited here, covers other eggshell membranes, not Reggenerate®.

This is not a judgment on hydrolysates: for a drink, it is even the most logical form. Our eggshell membrane guide for formulators details its composition, and our comparison of joint supplement ingredients positions it against glucosamine or collagen.

Frequently asked questions

Can a native membrane be used in a drink?

Not in a clear drink: it is insoluble and will not dissolve. For that format, a hydrolyzed membrane is better suited. In a capsule, tablet, gummy, powder or bar, the native form works without difficulty.

Which claim can go on an eggshell membrane food supplement?

Neither the native form nor the hydrolyzed form has an authorized health claim in Europe. Brands pair it with an authorized nutrient, for example vitamin C, which contributes to normal collagen formation for the normal function of cartilage, or manganese for the normal formation of connective tissue. Check the exact wording in the EU register of claims.

How can you tell whether a membrane is native or hydrolyzed?

Ask your supplier for a description of the process, the water solubility and, for a hydrolysate, the molecular weight profile of the peptides. Solubility gives a first clue, but only the description of the process is authoritative.