Reggenerate logo
SKIN & HAIR

Hair and Nail Supplement Ingredients: Which to Choose?

09 Nov 2026 • 8 min read

By Chloé Vernet, Sales & Marketing Manager at Circul'Egg

Biotin is the default active in hair and nail formulas. Yet in Europe, it has no authorized claim for nails. And a systematic review published in 2017 found only 18 documented clinical cases of improvement with biotin, all in people with an underlying condition or deficiency (Patel et al., 2017).

A good ingredient for a hair and nail supplement does not do the job on its own. A convincing formula rests on two tiers: micronutrients with an authorized claim (biotin, zinc, selenium, copper), which carry the message on pack, and a functional active (keratin, sulfur amino acids, collagen, eggshell membrane) that brings differentiation and studies to present to professionals. Here is what these actives are worth, and what your label will actually be able to say.

Biotin, zinc, selenium: what do the studies say when there is no deficiency?

Biotin, between rare deficiency and underestimated deficiency

The 2017 review concludes that biotin may be useful in cases of deficiency or in certain conditions such as brittle nail syndrome, but that evidence is lacking in healthy people (Patel et al., 2017). A Swiss study nonetheless measured a biotin deficit in 38% of women consulting for hair loss. Its author still rejects systematic supplementation as long as the deficiency and its link to the complaint have not been established (Trüeb, 2016).

On nails, the data are old and small: a 25% increase in thickness in 8 patients with brittle nails supplemented with biotin, measured by electron microscopy (Colombo et al., 1990). A signal, not a demonstration. Another point worth knowing: at high blood concentrations, biotin can interfere with certain laboratory assays, notably thyroid panels (Dasgupta, 2022).

Zinc, selenium and iron: useful when lacking, not beyond

A review of vitamins and minerals in hair loss describes zinc, selenium and iron as involved in the hair follicle cycle, with a role that is “important but not entirely clear”. The authors see deficiency as a modifiable risk factor and call for large placebo-controlled trials (Almohanna et al., 2018).

For iron, a Cleveland Clinic review judges the evidence insufficient to recommend supplementation in people losing their hair without anemia, and points to the risk of overload (Trost et al., 2006). For selenium, more is frankly not better: in a poisoning outbreak linked to a misformulated supplement, 201 cases were recorded, with hair loss in 72% of people and discolored or brittle nails in 61%. The median dose ingested reached 41,749 µg per day, against a recommended intake of 55 µg (MacFarquhar et al., 2010).

Keratin and sulfur amino acids: supplying the building blocks of the fiber

The keratin in hair and nails owes its strength to its disulfide bonds, formed by cysteine. Hence the idea of supplying cystine, methionine or hydrolyzed keratin directly. The logic is appealing; the data remain thin.

  • Hydrolyzed keratin: a randomized double-blind trial tested a poultry feather keratin hydrolysate at 500 or 1,000 mg per day for 90 days in adult women. The authors report improvements in skin parameters, hair and nail shine, and nail hardness compared with placebo (Tursi et al., 2024).
  • Cystine and millet extract: an open-label study followed 112 people with mild diffuse hair loss for 12 weeks, using a combination of millet extract, L-cystine, pantothenic acid and biotin. Hair density increased from baseline (Proksch and Bartylla, 2026). Without a placebo group, the effect cannot be attributed to any one component.
  • Methionine and brewer's yeast: very present on the market, they have few published trials of their own on hair or nails. Brewer's yeast remains above all a natural source of B vitamins.

Collagen, an active geared more toward nails

On nails, the most cited study is an open-label trial: 25 participants with brittle nails took 2.5 g of collagen peptides per day for 24 weeks, with a 12% increase in nail growth rate and 42% fewer broken nails (Hexsel et al., 2017). Encouraging, but with no placebo. On hair, data for collagen alone remain scarce, and 2.5 g per day calls for a stick pack, a powder or several capsules.

Eggshell membrane and hair: what does the randomized trial show?

Eggshell membrane contains collagen, hyaluronic acid and elastin, and its fibers are rich in disulfide bonds: a cysteine-rich protein specific to the membrane has been identified there (Kodali et al., 2011). On paper, it therefore sits at the crossroads of the sulfur building-block logic and the supporting-matrix logic.

On the clinical side, a randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trial was published in 2020: 88 healthy middle-aged adults, split into two groups of 44, took 450 mg per day of a hydrolyzed eggshell membrane or a placebo for 12 weeks. Hair was measured by digital trichoscopy, skin by imaging, nails by questionnaire (Kalman and Hewlings, 2020). Reported results:

  • hair: a significant effect on thickness, reduced breakage and improved growth at 4, 8 and 12 weeks compared with placebo;
  • skin: significant improvement in the appearance of crow's feet from week 4 and in skin tone at week 8;
  • nails: no subjective improvement in appearance, strength or growth.

Let us be honest about its scope. It is a single trial, of modest size, on a hydrolyzed membrane, meaning one cut into fragments to make it soluble. It was not conducted on Reggenerate®, which is a native membrane, and its results cannot be attributed to it. It does show, however, that the category is starting to be studied on hair with a controlled methodology.

Hair and nail actives compared

ActiveWhat the studies showEU claim for hair or nailsFormulator watch-point
BiotinBenefit documented mainly in cases of deficiency or diseaseNormal hair (none for nails)Interference with certain laboratory assays at high doses
ZincRole in the follicle cycle, effect beyond deficiency uncertainNormal hair and nailsDose relative to the NRV
SeleniumSame; hair loss in cases of massive overdoseNormal hair and nailsNarrow margin between useful intake and excess
CopperRole in pigmentationNormal hair pigmentationRelevant for a “color” message
IronLink between deficiency and hair loss debatedNoneNo supplementation by default outside deficiency
Hydrolyzed keratin1 randomized trial, 500 or 1,000 mg, 90 days, womenNoneOne to two capsules
Cystine, methionineData mostly in combination, open-label studiesNoneContribution of each active hard to isolate
Hydrolyzed collagenNails: 2.5 g, 24 weeks, 25 people, no placeboNoneStick pack, powder or multiple capsules
Eggshell membrane (including Reggenerate®, native eggshell membrane)1 randomized trial on hydrolyzed membrane, 450 mg, 12 weeks: hair and skin, no effect on nailsNoneReggenerate® at 300 mg: one capsule, gummy possible; egg allergen

What can your label say about hair and nails?

The European list of authorized claims (Regulation (EU) No 432/2012) includes, among others: “Biotin contributes to the maintenance of normal hair”, “Selenium contributes to the maintenance of normal hair”, “Selenium contributes to the maintenance of normal nails” and “Copper contributes to normal hair pigmentation”. Zinc also has claims for the maintenance of normal hair and normal nails. Each requires the product to be at least a “source” of the nutrient, i.e. 15% of the nutrient reference value per daily portion. Always check the exact wording in the EU register before printing.

Two points deserve your attention. Biotin opens no door on nails: for a “nails” message, it is zinc or selenium that must be dosed. And no “growth”, “anti-hair loss” or “density” claim appears in the authorized list. These words, common on shelf, expose the brand to regulatory risk, and a food cannot claim to prevent or treat a disease such as alopecia (Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, Article 7). Eggshell membrane, keratin, collagen and sulfur amino acids have no claim of their own: their studies serve the professional argument, not the pack.

How to build a hair and nail formula that holds up

Frankly, we advise against building a formula on high-dose biotin alone. It opens no more claims than at the “source” dose, it does not cover nails, and it can complicate your consumers' blood tests. The approach we recommend is more restrained: biotin, zinc and selenium at the doses that unlock the claims, copper if you talk about color, then a functional active that gives the formula its personality.

For this functional tier, eggshell membrane has a format advantage. At Circul'Egg, we chose a native, non-hydrolyzed membrane, separated from the shell by a 100% mechanical, solvent-free process that preserves its original matrix: type I, V and X collagen, elastin, hyaluronic acid, glucosamine and chondroitin. At 300 mg per day, Reggenerate®, native eggshell membrane, leaves room for micronutrients in a single capsule, and also works in tablets, gummies, powders or bars. It is made from upcycled eggshells and developed by Circul'Egg, a company based in Janzé, Brittany, with ISO and HACCP certifications. Our eggshell membrane guide for formulators details its composition.

To save time, our ready-to-market offer starts from this base. And present the studies for what they are: serious but still young signals, obtained on specific ingredients. That is what makes a sales argument credible in front of a pharmacist.

Frequently asked questions

Which ingredient should you choose for a nail supplement?

For the claim, zinc and selenium, which contribute to the maintenance of normal nails. For the functional active, hydrolyzed collagen has an open-label study on brittle nails. The randomized trial on hydrolyzed eggshell membrane, for its part, showed no effect on nails.

Can you write “supports hair growth” on a food supplement?

No, this wording does not appear in the European list of authorized claims. Brands rely on “contributes to the maintenance of normal hair” (biotin, zinc, selenium) or on normal hair pigmentation (copper), with the exact wording of the register.

Do the results of the 2020 trial apply to Reggenerate®?

No. That trial tested a hydrolyzed eggshell membrane at 450 mg per day. Reggenerate® is a native, non-hydrolyzed membrane, recommended at 300 mg per day, and was not evaluated in that study. Both belong to the same ingredient category, but their results are not interchangeable.