On labels, collagen is sold by number: type I for skin, type II for joints. The digestive tract, for its part, does not read labels. A hydrolyzed collagen is broken down into peptides and amino acids well before it reaches the dermis or the cartilage, and what ends up in the blood no longer looks like a “type”.
The difference between type 1 and type 2 collagen matters above all when the collagen is undenatured. For a skin formula, the trials almost all involve hydrolyzed collagen peptides, mostly type I (bovine, porcine or marine), at several grams per day. For a joint formula, two logics coexist: hydrolyzed collagen in grams, or undenatured type II collagen at 40 mg per day, whose value lies precisely in its intact structure.
Where are type I, II, III, V and X collagens found in the body?
The collagen family has 28 members (Ricard-Blum, 2011). To read the market, five are enough. A 2021 review of cartilage collagens paints a precise picture of them (Alcaide-Ruggiero et al., 2021):
- Type I: the most abundant. More than 90% of the organic mass of bone, and the main collagen of tendons, skin, ligaments and the cornea. Absent from healthy hyaline cartilage.
- Type II: confined to cartilage, the vitreous body and the intervertebral discs. More than 90 to 95% of the collagen in mature articular cartilage.
- Type III: 5 to 20% of total collagen, in arteries and hollow organs, and associated with type I in skin and tendons.
- Type V: a minor type, it integrates into type I fibrils and regulates their geometry. In mouse embryos lacking collagen V, fibrils barely form at all (Wenstrup et al., 2004).
- Type X: produced by hypertrophic chondrocytes, present in hypertrophic cartilage and the calcified zone, at the interface with bone, where it is associated with mineralization. About 1% of the collagen in adult articular cartilage.
In tissues, these types do not live apart: type I assembles with type III in skin, and with type V in bone and tendons. It therefore does not “make” skin on its own.
Where do the collagens sold to brands come from?
They are co-products of animal supply chains: bovine (bone, tendons, hide), porcine (skin) and, increasingly, marine (fish skin, scales and bones) (León-López et al., 2019). These tissues are dominated by type I. A bovine, porcine or marine collagen is therefore, in the vast majority of cases, a type I collagen, accompanied by type III when it comes from skin.
Type II comes from cartilage: the most studied undenatured form is extracted from chicken sternum (Lugo et al., 2016). Eggshell membrane, for its part, brings together type I, V and X collagens in a single matrix (Arias et al., 1992).
In a specification, origin often weighs more than type. Fish is an allergen that must be declared, egg too, and bovine or porcine sources exclude certain target groups for dietary reasons or personal convictions.
Hydrolyzed or undenatured: why the state matters more than the number
To hydrolyze a collagen, its triple helix is first denatured by heat, then cut up by enzymes. The result is peptides of 3 to 6 kDa, versus 285 to 300 kDa for the native molecule (León-López et al., 2019). The structure that defined the “type” is gone. Digestion carries on the work: after ingestion of a gelatin hydrolysate, nine hydroxyproline-containing di- and tripeptides are found in plasma, Pro-Hyp first among them (Ichikawa et al., 2010). It is to these fragments and to free amino acids that research attributes the observed effects, not to a type I collagen that would somehow relocate intact into the dermis.
The clinical data point the same way. A meta-analysis of 26 randomized trials (1,721 participants) concludes that hydrolyzed collagen improves skin hydration and elasticity compared with placebo, with no significant difference between collagen sources on elasticity. The effect on hydration varies with source and duration, and the authors note several biases in the included trials (Pu et al., 2023).
Undenatured collagen follows an entirely different logic. Undenatured type II retains its structure, and it is this structure that is thought to act, through an immune mechanism called oral tolerance, at 40 mg per day (Gupta and Maffulli, 2025). In the 180-day trial conducted in 191 people with knee osteoarthritis, it outperformed both placebo and the glucosamine plus chondroitin combination on the WOMAC score (Lugo et al., 2016). A hydrolyzed type II collagen therefore cannot claim the results of an undenatured type II.
The table: type, location, sources and studied form
| Type | Where it is found in the body | Market sources | Form and dose studied in supplements |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type I | Bone, skin, tendons, ligaments, cornea | Bovine, porcine, marine | Hydrolyzed peptides: 2.5 to 5 g per day for skin, 10 g per day for joints in athletes |
| Type II | Cartilage, vitreous body, intervertebral discs | Chicken sternum | Undenatured, 40 mg per day for 180 days |
| Type III | Arteries, hollow organs, skin alongside type I | Supplied with type I by skin hydrolysates | Rarely promoted on its own |
| Type V | Associated with type I (bone, tendons, cornea, skin) | Type I-rich tissues, eggshell membrane | No trial on isolated type V to our knowledge |
| Type X | Hypertrophic cartilage, calcified zone | Eggshell membrane | No trial on isolated type X to our knowledge |
| Eggshell membrane, types I, V and X (including Reggenerate®, native eggshell membrane) | The thin film lining the inside of the shell | Eggshells | Whole membrane, 300 to 500 mg per day in joint trials |
Type 1 or type 2 collagen: which to choose for a skin or joint formula?
Skin formula. Frankly, we advise against building a sales argument on “type I” alone: almost every hydrolysate on the market is type I, so the number will not set you apart. Look at the dose and duration tested. In the trial by Proksch et al. (2014), 69 women aged 35 to 55 took 2.5 g or 5 g of collagen peptides per day for 8 weeks: skin elasticity improved significantly compared with placebo in both groups, while hydration did not reach significance. At these doses, hydrolyzed collagen is an ingredient for powders, stick packs or drinks, not capsules. Ask your supplier for trials conducted on its own hydrolysate.
Joint formula. Format decides. In powder form, hydrolyzed collagen holds up: 10 g per day for 24 weeks in 147 athletes improved several parameters of activity-related joint pain compared with placebo (Clark et al., 2008). In a capsule, tablet or gummy, actives that work at a low dose take over: undenatured type II collagen at 40 mg, or eggshell membrane at 300 to 500 mg. Our comparison of joint supplement ingredients details the evidence for each.
What about eggshell membrane, with its type I, V and X collagens?
The shell membrane contains type X collagen, which until then had only been described in hypertrophic cartilage, something the researchers themselves found surprising (Carrino et al., 1996). It also contains type I, partly masked by type X during labeling (Arias et al., 1991), and type V. This type X is heavily cross-linked and insoluble (Arias et al., 1997): a matrix built to last, not an isolated peptide.
Let us be honest: no study shows that an ingested type X collagen acts as such. What has been tested in humans is the whole membrane. A 2024 meta-analysis identified seven randomized placebo-controlled trials in people with knee osteoarthritis and concludes that the total WOMAC score improved significantly (García-Muñoz et al., 2024). In another trial, a minimally processed native membrane at 300 mg per day, in 150 participants over 12 weeks, did not separate the groups on the primary endpoint, but improved the KOOS “pain” and “daily living” scores from the first week onward (Kiers and Bult, 2020). These trials involve other eggshell membranes, not Reggenerate®.
The membrane's argument is therefore not the number of its collagens, it is the whole matrix at a low dose: type I, V and X collagens, elastin, hyaluronic acid, glucosamine and chondroitin, naturally combined. At Circul'Egg, we chose to keep it native, non-hydrolyzed, separated from the shell by a 100% mechanical, solvent-free process. Reggenerate®, native eggshell membrane, is dosed at 300 mg per day and works in capsules, tablets, gummies, powders and bars. Our eggshell membrane guide for formulators details its composition.
What your label will be able to say
The collagen number changes nothing on the regulatory side. In 2011, EFSA issued a negative opinion on hydrolyzed collagen and the maintenance of joints (EFSA, 2011), and eggshell membrane has no health claim of its own. The on-pack message is therefore built with nutrients whose claim is authorized under Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006, starting with vitamin C, which contributes to normal collagen formation for the normal function of skin, cartilage and bones. For skin, biotin, zinc, niacin, riboflavin or vitamin A round out the range. Check the exact wording in the EU register of claims before printing.
Frequently asked questions
Is marine collagen better for skin than bovine collagen?
The data do not allow that conclusion. The meta-analysis by Pu et al. (2023) finds no significant difference between sources on elasticity, and an effect that varies by source on hydration. The choice is made instead on allergens, the target group's diet, taste and cost.
Is a hydrolyzed type II collagen equivalent to an undenatured type II?
No. Undenatured type II is studied at 40 mg per day for its intact structure. Once hydrolyzed, it becomes a source of peptides dosed in grams, like the other hydrolyzed collagens. The results of one do not apply to the other.
Can eggshell membrane replace a hydrolyzed collagen in a skin formula?
They are not the same ingredients. Hydrolyzed collagen supplies grams of peptides, with published skin trials. Eggshell membrane supplies, at 300 mg, a matrix that combines collagens, elastin and hyaluronic acid, and its published trials focus mainly on joints. In a small beauty format, it makes sense as a base, combined with nutrients whose skin claim is authorized.